Skip to content

Borg and McEnroe: two racquets, two tennis icons, and the rivalry that changed Wimbledon

Bjorn Borg and John McEnroe’s rivalry is remembered because they looked like they’d been invented to annoy each other.

Borg was the Ice Man and McEnroe was the explosion.

Borg seemed to treat Centre Court like a library with a net. McEnroe treated it like a courtroom where he was both barrister and defendant.

One kept everything inside. The other couldn’t help but outsource his inner monologue directly to the umpire.

That’s why two very different tennis racquets in BUDDS’ Match Point: The Tennis Memorabilia Timed Auction, make such a wonderful pairing.

On one side is a Bjorn Borg Grays of Cambridge used and autographed tennis racquet, connected to his much-discussed comeback after years away from the game.

On the other is a John McEnroe smashed and autographed Wilson Jack Kramer Pro Staff wooden tennis racquet, broken at Wimbledon around 1977-80 and later signed with the perfect inscription: “Thanks for the memories, Good or bad!”

Together, they’re not just two pieces of tennis memorabilia. They’re two personalities in wooden form.

One speaks to discipline, routine, mystique and the sadness of a comeback that never quite became the fairytale.

The other is pure McEnroe: talent, theatre, anger, genius, chaos and a racquet that personifies his fiery character.

Borg, the calm before and after the storm

Bjorn Borg wasn’t just a tennis player in the 1970s, he was a phenomenon.

Long hair, headband, Fila shirt, Donnay racquet, Diadora shoes and that strange, almost unsettling calm. He looked like he’d wandered out of a Scandinavian fashion shoot and started winning Grand Slam titles as a side hustle.

Except there was nothing accidental about him.

Borg was a machine of focus and stamina, but not a boring machine. More like a sports car that never revved loudly because it knew perfectly well what was under the bonnet.

He won five consecutive Wimbledon singles titles from 1976 to 1980, and six French Opens. Eleven major singles titles in total, achieved before most players’ careers get going.

Then, at just 26, he walked away.

At that age, most elite athletes are meant to be entering their peak. Borg had already climbed the mountain, planted the flag, taken the photographs and decided he had had enough of the weather.

His retirement in 1983 shocked tennis. He’d been the biggest star in the sport, the man whose appeal stretched beyond tennis into genuine celebrity. “Borgmania” was real. He was followed like a rock star, admired like a champion and watched like a mystery.

That mystery was part of the attraction. Nobody knew what he was thinking or how he was feeling.

His opponents certainly didn’t, which was probably the point.

The comeback racquet

The Borg racquet in this BUDDS auction comes from a fascinating later chapter.

After around eight years away, Borg attempted a comeback in the early 1990s. By then, tennis had changed.

The sport had moved on. Technology had moved on. The players had moved on. The old wooden racquet era had been pushed aside by graphite and modern materials.

Borg, however, remained Borg. When he decided to return, he wanted the tools that felt like his own. The story behind this Grays of Cambridge racquet is brilliant because it says so much about him.

Coming out of retirement, Borg approached Donnay for the racquets he loved, only to find that technology had moved on and they no longer made those wooden frames. Donnay directed him to Grays of Cambridge, specialists in wooden sports equipment and bespoke wooden frames.

Borg wanted racquets that could take high tension, with an extended leather grip to suit his distinctive double-handed backhand. That’s a very specific request.

Borg was famously particular about his equipment. He insisted on natural gut strung at 76 to 78lbs, far tighter than modern tensions. The result was that frames could become almost unusable after each use.

Which is wonderfully absurd. Most of us get annoyed when a phone charger stops working after two years. Borg was getting through racquets because they were strung with the tension of a suspension bridge.

The comeback didn’t last long, but the racquets remain a reminder of a great champion trying to reconnect with the feeling that had once made him untouchable.

That’s what makes this lot so human. It’s not Borg at the height of Borgmania, it’s Borg after the silence.

A champion returning to a sport that had moved on, carrying the same habits, the same standards and the same old need for control.

McEnroe, the artist with steam coming out of his ears

Then there’s John McEnroe.

If Borg was silence, McEnroe was surround sound.

The easy version is to remember the arguments, the umpire confrontations, the “You cannot be serious!” line and the sense that every disputed call was a personal attack on justice and John McEnroe himself.

The shouting was part of the show, but it can also hide how brilliant he was. McEnroe wasn’t just angry. He was an artist.

His touch at the net was extraordinary. He didn’t play tennis like someone trying to batter the ball into submission. He shaped it, teased it, guided it, found angles that seemed impossible.

One description of him as “Pablo Picasso using a tennis racquet instead of a paintbrush” feels right, even if Picasso probably broke fewer racquets.

McEnroe won seven major singles titles, nine major doubles titles and one major mixed doubles title. He was world No.1 in singles and doubles, won 77 singles titles and 72 doubles titles, and in 1984 produced one of the greatest seasons in tennis history, finishing 82-3.

That record is ridiculous. Eighty-two wins and three defeats. Most people have worse ratios trying to put a USB cable in the right way.

The most McEnroe object imaginable

The McEnroe lot in this auction is almost too perfect.

A smashed and autographed Wilson Jack Kramer Pro Staff wooden racquet from Wimbledon around 1977-80, broken on both sides of the head and held together by the strings.

That’s not just a racquet, it has its own personality. It’s signed by McEnroe in blue ink with the line: “Thanks for the memories, Good or bad!”

Honestly, you could hardly script it better. A smashed McEnroe Wimbledon racquet is already a collector’s dream because it captures what the public remembers so vividly: the temper, the drama, the combustion.

But the inscription adds humour and self-awareness.

McEnroe has spent the rest of his life half escaping, half embracing the McEnroe myth. The fact he signs this with “Good or bad” is perfect because the bad memories were usually still quite entertaining, unless you happened to be the umpire.

The racquet was gifted to a staff member at the residence where McEnroe would regularly stay during Wimbledon, and was later featured on Antiques Roadshow.

It’s a broken racquet with a Wimbledon connection, a personal gift story, a public TV appearance and the signature of the man most associated with tennis anger.

Borg v McEnroe: ice and fire

Of course, Borg and McEnroe will always be linked. Their rivalry was short compared with some, but its impact was enormous.

Borg and McEnroe were such a perfect contrast that it almost felt theatrical. The calm champion against the volatile challenger. The baseline rhythm against the serve-volley attack. The old king against the new threat.

Their 1980 Wimbledon final is still regarded as one of the greatest tennis matches ever played.

Borg won in five sets, 1-6, 7-5, 6-3, 6-7, 8-6, but even the scoreline doesn’t fully explain the drama. The fourth-set tiebreak alone became part of tennis folklore, a 34-point monster in which McEnroe saved match points, Borg saved set points, and everyone watched in awe.

Borg later called it a match he would remember for the rest of his life. McEnroe has said there’s a magic when their names are mentioned together.

You can’t really say Borg without thinking of McEnroe, and you cannot really say McEnroe without Borg walking calmly into the background, looking like he’s never raised his voice in a restaurant.

Then came the 1981 Wimbledon final, when McEnroe finally beat Borg at Centre Court.

For Borg, something had shifted. The fire was going out. He reached the US Open final later that year, but soon walked away from the game.

For McEnroe, the win was part of his rise to the top. Tennis had changed hands.

Own the rivalry

That’s why these two auction lots make such a strong combined story.

The Borg racquet is about memory, return and the difficulty of recapturing a past self.

The McEnroe racquet is about release, emotion and the theatre of a player who could never hide what was happening inside him.

Borg’s racquet is intact, carefully made, signed and tied to a comeback that was built on old habits in a new game.

McEnroe’s racquet is broken, held together by the strings, signed with a joke and tied to the raw emotion that made him unforgettable.

You couldn’t ask for a better contrast.

Control and chaos. Silence and shouting. The Ice Man and the firestarter.

A racquet from a comeback. A racquet from a combustion.

Two legends, two objects, one rivalry that helped turn tennis into theatre.

That’s sporting history. And with BUDDS, it is history you can own.

Own your passion.

Written by Peter Jones, The Football Historian. 

Instagram

Youtube

We use cookies to give you the best experience of using this website. By continuing to use this site, you accept our use of cookies. Please read our Cookie Policy for more information.